top of page

Can You Cut Down a Tree With a Bird Nest in It?

Writer: Brinko Tree Service
Brinko Tree Service
23 minutes ago
8 min read

Not while the nest is active, and not an eagle nest without a federal permit. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) says the Migratory Bird Treaty Act makes it illegal to destroy a nest holding eggs or chicks, or one young birds still depend on, but that the act "does not contain any prohibition that applies to the destruction of a bird nest alone (without eggs or birds in it), provided that no possession occurs during destruction." Timing your tree removal for the months when nests sit empty is the simplest way to plan around the rule.

 

Pennsylvania's dates come from three public sources. USFWS's bald eagle disturbance permit conditions, in the August 25, 2026 version, list Pennsylvania's eagle breeding season as January 1 to July 31; a USFWS table lists October 1 to March 31 as the inactive season for the northern long-eared bat in Pennsylvania summer habitat outside its swarming and staging areas; and Penn State Extension says eastern bluebird pairs "begin breeding in early April." Read together, those dates point to late fall and winter for removals near songbird nests and bat roosts, with one catch: eagle season opens January 1. This post covers the federal nest rule, active nests, covered birds, Pennsylvania nesting times, eagles, bats and removal timing.


safe tree removal

What Does Federal Law Say About Bird Nests?

 

As of late 2026, USFWS says "Most bird nests are protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA)." According to its page on the act, the law bars taking protected migratory birds, which includes killing, capturing, selling, trading and transporting them, without the agency's authorization.

 

The nest rule turns on whether the nest is in use. An active nest holds eggs or chicks, or young birds still depend on it. USFWS describes an inactive nest as one that "contains no eggs or chicks and is no longer being used by birds for breeding," and says "It is usually required that you wait for the nest to become inactive" before destroying it.

 

Two more points from the same USFWS page matter for a tree job. Keeping a nest taken from a tree or found on the ground is illegal without a permit. And nest destruction "that results in the unpermitted take of migratory birds, or their eggs, is illegal and fully prosecutable under the MBTA."

 

Permits to remove an active nest exist, but USFWS says they are "usually only issued when the particular nest is causing a human health or safety concern or the birds are in immediate danger." For a specific tree, the people to ask are USFWS and, for state wildlife law, the Pennsylvania Game Commission.

 

How Can You Tell Whether a Nest Is Active?

 

Look, from a distance, before anyone cuts. Eggs, chicks or young birds that still depend on the nest make it active under the USFWS rule. USFWS notes that nests inside tree cavities and holes are hard to check.

 

Where birds build changes what you can see. Cornell Lab of Ornithology says American robin nests "are typically in the lower half of a tree, although they can be built as high as the treetop." House wrens, Cornell says, "nest in old woodpecker holes, natural crevices, and nest boxes," and Penn State Extension says bluebird nests in cavities and boxes are usually 5 to 12 feet above the ground, though some have been found as high as 20 feet.

 

An old nest is not proof of an empty one. Cornell says great horned owls "usually adopt a nest that was built by another species," so last year's stick nest can hold a new tenant.

 

When you cannot tell, follow the USFWS line and wait until the nest is inactive. For the dead tree itself, Brinko's guide to the safety of leaving a dead tree standing covers the risk side.

 

Which Birds Does the Migratory Bird Treaty Act Cover?

 

Native wild birds named on the federal list at 50 CFR 10.13, which as of late 2026 was last amended on July 31, 2023. Familiar Pennsylvania birds on it include:

 

  • Blue jay

  • Northern mockingbird

  • American robin

  • House wren

  • Northern cardinal

  • Eastern bluebird

  • Bald eagle

 

The Federal Register notice behind that 2023 update put the total at 1,106 protected species. USFWS says the act covers only species native to the United States or its territories, and the house sparrow, European starling and rock pigeon do not appear on the list.

 

That federal gap does not settle state law, so ask the Pennsylvania Game Commission about any species before you act.

 

When Do Birds Nest in Pennsylvania?

 

Spring and summer, varying by species. Penn State Extension's bluebird guide gives the clearest Pennsylvania timeline: pairs "begin breeding in early April," the eggs hatch within 12 to 14 days, and both parents feed the young in the nest for 15 to 20 days.

 

Add those numbers and one bluebird brood occupies a nest for roughly four to five weeks after incubation starts. Penn State says "Most adults will raise two broods in a season," so a box on a fence post in Murrysville or a cavity in a dead limb in Irwin can stay busy from April into summer.

 

Other common birds run on their own clocks. The Pennsylvania Game Commission says male cardinals begin singing in February and March, that cardinal nests sit 1 to 15 feet up in dense shrubs, and that cardinals can raise up to four broods a year, though "a pair typically produces one or two broods." For hummingbirds, the Game Commission says "Typically, egg laying in Pennsylvania runs from May to July," with the nest usually in a deciduous tree 10 to 40 feet up.

 

Cornell's NestWatch adds a rule of thumb: "Nests found early in the spring tend to belong to non-migratory residents," while migrants breed later, and the American goldfinch nests in late summer.

 

What If the Nest Belongs to a Bald Eagle?

 

Then the calendar works differently. USFWS says nests of bald and golden eagles "are also always protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act. Destruction of these nests requires a permit at all times, whether or not they are occupied and in-use."

 

USFWS's eagle disturbance general permit conditions, version dated August 25, 2026, list Pennsylvania's bald eagle breeding season as January 1 to July 31. The same document says the general permit does not authorize "Take of eagle nests, including removing the nest or nest tree," outside a narrow prescribed burn exception.

 

For work near any eagle nest, in use or not, the conditions require holders of that permit to:

 

  • Minimize overstory tree removal within 660 feet of the nest

  • "Do not clearcut any areas within 330 feet of the nest tree at any time."

  • Keep as many mature trees as possible within 660 feet

  • When felling trees near the nest, "take all practical precautions to avoid contact with the nest tree, especially the crown," and "Use a professional tree service whenever possible."

 

A second set applies only when a nest is in use or occupied, and the document defines an in-use nest as one that "contains one or more viable eggs or dependent young." Those conditions move chipping, burning or disposal of cut vegetation at least 660 feet from the nest and, for timber or forestry work, keep chainsaws out of the 330 foot zone.

 

These are permit terms, not a statute, and USFWS calls them a living document that may be revised. If an eagle nest is anywhere near your trees, contact USFWS before planning any cutting.

 

Do Bats Limit When You Can Cut Trees in Pennsylvania?

 

They can. On November 29, 2022, USFWS published a final rule to reclassify the northern long-eared bat as endangered. The agency says the species faces extinction because of white-nose syndrome, which it calls "the predominant threat by far." Hibernacula counts of the bat have declined by 97 to 100 percent across its range, USFWS says.

 

The bats use trees much of the year. USFWS says that in summer and parts of spring and fall they may roost "underneath bark, in cavities or in crevices of both live trees and snags, or dead trees," and spend winter "hibernating in caves and mines, called hibernacula."

 

That is where the Pennsylvania window comes from. USFWS's inactive season table lists October 1 to March 31 for Pennsylvania, saying that during those dates the bats "are not likely to be present in forested habitat outside of fall swarming and spring staging areas," which USFWS expects within five miles of hibernacula.

 

Older USFWS conservation recommendations from 2016, written before the endangered listing, said to remove trees outside the pup season (June 1 to July 31) and/or the active season (April 1 to October 31). A January 2026 USFWS Pennsylvania Field Office review of a pipeline project in the state noted tree cutting planned for October 16 to March 31. Those dates were written for projects, so ask USFWS how they apply to your property.

 

When Is the Best Time to Remove a Tree Near Nesting Birds?

 

By the USFWS and Penn State dates, late fall and winter, unless an eagle nest is nearby. The bats' Pennsylvania inactive season begins October 1, bluebirds start breeding in early April, and eagle season opens January 1.

 

A tree that threatens a house in June is a different case. Because USFWS ties active-nest permits to human health and safety concerns or birds in immediate danger, call USFWS before cutting a hazard tree that holds an active nest.

 

A dead tree away from buildings may be worth leaving. Penn State Extension says "Because people have removed cavity trees from many habitats, suitable nest sites often limit the number of bluebirds in an area."

 

When a tree does need to come down, Brinko Tree Service can take it out with precision rigging if it stands close to a house, fence or utility line, and our lot clearing takes out trees, dense brush and overgrown vegetation. For seasonal planning, read the best time of year to remove trees in Western Pennsylvania and what steps are involved in lot clearing in Irwin, PA.

 

FAQ

 

Why is a bird's nest illegal?

 

Taking or keeping one is what the law restricts. USFWS says "It is also illegal for anyone to keep a nest they take out of a tree or find on the ground unless they have a permit," and destroying a nest with eggs, chicks or dependent young breaks the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. USFWS can answer questions about a specific nest.

 

What month do most birds lay eggs?

 

It varies by species. In Pennsylvania, Penn State Extension puts the start of bluebird breeding in early April, and the Game Commission says hummingbird egg laying runs from May to July. Cornell's NestWatch notes that nests found early in spring tend to belong to year-round residents, with migrants breeding later.

 

What happens if you disturb a wren's nest?

 

You may break federal law. The house wren is on the Migratory Bird Treaty Act list, and USFWS says destroying a nest with eggs or chicks, or one young birds still depend on, is illegal. Cornell says house wrens raise one or two broods and use woodpecker holes, crevices and nest boxes, so wait until a wren cavity is empty before the tree comes down.

 

Is killing blue jays illegal?

 

Yes, without federal authorization. The blue jay is on the 50 CFR 10.13 list, and according to USFWS's page on the act, the law bars taking protected species, which includes killing them. For state rules, contact the Pennsylvania Game Commission.

 

Do mockingbirds come back to the same nest every year?

 

Rarely. Cornell Lab of Ornithology says "Northern Mockingbirds rarely ever reuse their nests." They raise two to three broods and build in shrubs and trees 3 to 10 feet up, sometimes as high as 60 feet.

 

What month do bluebirds lay their eggs?

 

Starting in April, in Pennsylvania. Penn State Extension says pairs begin breeding in early April, each clutch has three to six pale blue eggs, and the adults feed the young out of the nest for another 10 days after they leave it.

 

Tree Removal and Lot Clearing From Brinko Tree Service

 

Brinko Tree Service takes down hazardous, dead, diseased and unwanted trees and clears lots for homes and businesses in Harrison City, Irwin, Murrysville, Greensburg and elsewhere in Westmoreland and Allegheny counties. Brinko is licensed and insured in Pennsylvania with close to 20 years of service in Western Pennsylvania, and a free estimate lets you price and plan the work before nesting season.

 

Visit Brinko Tree Service or call 412-373-7450 today. Contact us for more information.


brinko tree service

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page