Can You Cut Tree Roots Without Killing the Tree?

You can cut some tree roots without killing the tree, but where you cut matters more than how many small roots you remove. Research by Dr. E. Thomas Smiley, published in 2008 in the journal Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, found measurable losses in stability when trenches came within three times the trunk diameter of a tree, and he concluded that trenching should stay at least that far away. The University of Florida's root pruning guidelines give a similar rule: no closer than three times the trunk diameter and preferably five.
The bigger risk is falling, not dying. In Smiley's willow oak study, severing a single large root near the trunk reduced the force needed to tip the tree by an average of 12%, and cutting half of the exposed buttress roots reduced it by 30%. A 2014 follow-up on red maples by Smiley, Holmes and Fraedrich found a nearly direct linear relationship: the first root cut reduced stability by about 13%, one-third of the roots by about 35%, and half by about 47%. This guide covers how close is too close, how to cut roots when you have to, and when removal is the safer option.

Why Is Cutting Roots Riskier Than It Looks?
A tree's large roots near the trunk, called buttress roots, anchor it against wind. Smiley's research measured what happens to that anchor when those roots are cut.
In the 2014 study, ten plantation-grown red maples with 6 to 10 buttress roots each had those roots severed one at a time near the trunk. Smiley's team pulled trees to a one-degree lean and recorded how much force it took before and after cutting. The loss in holding strength showed up in those pull tests right after the cuts were made. To confirm the one-degree test reflects real failure, a third of the trees in the 2008 study were pulled all the way to failure, and the two measurements correlated with an r-squared of 0.76. A tree that looks fine after root work is not necessarily as well anchored as it was before.
How Close to the Trunk Is Too Close?
Use the trunk diameter as your ruler. Measure across the trunk at about chest height, then multiply:
3 times the trunk diameter: Smiley's minimum distance for linear trenching, where measurable stability loss began in his study.
5 times the trunk diameter: the University of Florida's preferred distance, and the distance at which Smiley's willow oaks showed no significant change.
6 to 8 inches per inch of trunk diameter: a more conservative guideline the University of Florida also cites.
For a tree with a 20-inch trunk, three times the diameter is 60 inches, or 5 feet from the trunk. Five times is a little over 8 feet. A sidewalk, patio or driveway close to a tree can easily sit inside those distances, so repairs there deserve a plan before anyone starts digging.
What If Roots Are Lifting a Sidewalk or Driveway?
This is the most common reason homeowners want to cut roots. Before cutting, consider the alternatives:
Reroute or reshape the hardscape. Moving a path or narrowing a slab can leave the root alone.
Cut only what sits outside the safe distance. A root under a slab 10 feet from a 20-inch tree is a different decision than one 3 feet from the trunk.
Decide between the tree and the slab. If the only fix requires cutting large roots close to the trunk, removing the tree may be safer than leaving a weakened tree beside a house or driveway.
Our posts on whether tree roots can damage driveways or sidewalks and how root systems can damage your foundation cover the damage side of this decision.
How Should Roots Be Cut When It Has to Happen?
Start below ground with a phone call. The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission says homeowners and contractors must call 811 at least three business days before starting any digging or excavation project. Root cutting usually means digging along the root, so the call comes first.
Then keep the cut clean. The University of Florida's guidelines say to prune roots only with sharp tools to avoid tearing behind the cut. A clean cut with a saw is better than ripping roots out with a backhoe bucket, which tears roots rather than cutting them.
Keep the work on one side if you can. The University of Florida notes research showing that roots on one side of very young trees could be cut completely at five times the trunk diameter without affecting stability. Cuts spread around the trunk add up, as the step-by-step cuts in the red maple study showed.
What Are the Warning Signs After Roots Are Cut?
Watch the tree for the next few seasons, especially after storms. Signs that the anchor or the tree's health took too big a hit include:
A new lean, or soil heaving or cracking on one side of the trunk after wind
Thinning leaves or dead branches on the side where roots were cut
Mushrooms or decay at the cut roots or the base of the trunk
Our guide to warning signs of root failure explains what each of these means, and whether construction damage can make trees unstable covers root damage from larger projects.
When Is Removing the Tree the Better Choice?
Removal makes sense when the work you need requires cutting several large roots close to the trunk, when the tree already leans toward a house or driveway, or when the tree is declining for other reasons. Smiley's red maple results show why: cutting half of the buttress roots cut stability almost in half. A tree in that condition next to a home is a risk.
After removal, stump grinding clears the base so the sidewalk, patio or foundation work can go ahead without working around the stump.
FAQ
Will cutting one root kill my tree?
Usually not right away. The main concern with large roots near the trunk is stability: Smiley found that cutting a single root reduced the force needed to tip a tree by an average of 12%. His 2008 paper advises arborists to avoid cutting any tree roots near the trunk.
How far from the trunk can I cut roots?
At least three times the trunk diameter, and preferably five, according to Smiley's research and the University of Florida's guidelines.
Do I need to call 811 before cutting roots?
If you are digging, yes. The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission says homeowners must call 811 at least three business days before any digging or excavation project.
Is it better to cut roots or remove the tree?
It depends on how close to the trunk and how many large roots are involved. Cuts beyond five times the trunk diameter are low risk; several large cuts near the trunk can leave a tree unstable enough that removal is safer.
Does it matter what tool is used?
Yes. The University of Florida recommends sharp tools so roots are cut cleanly rather than torn.
Can root damage cause a healthy-looking tree to fall?
It can happen. The stability losses Smiley measured showed up right after the roots were cut, whether or not the crown showed any change.
Tree Removal and Stump Grinding From Brinko Tree Service
Brinko Tree Service, based at 1010 Sunset Blvd in Harrison City, serves Westmoreland and Allegheny Counties with nearly 20 years of experience. When root conflicts with a sidewalk, driveway, or foundation mean a tree has to go, the team provides tree removal and stump grinding so the repair can proceed, and pruning and trimming for trees that stay. Brinko is fully licensed and insured, follows OSHA and ANSI safety regulations with an OSHA safety site supervisor on every job site, and offers free estimates.
Visit Brinko Tree Service or call 412-373-7450 today. Contact us for more information.




Comments